Bobby "Boom Boom" Baxter, played by Joe Clark

Boom Boom signing in guests

Mary Rose Looney, played by Melissa Morse on left and Missy Scott-Walker, played by Erin Durham on right

Each table consisted of a team of detectives sifting through the evidence

more sifting than eating

Missy Scott-Walker, played by Erin Durham

Giavanni Fishi (standing), played by Jerry Deckard

Sheriff Mark Dobbs (for real!)

Stephanie Dobbs with Melissa

The Sheriff played by Michelle Deckard

Steve Lewis, James Todd, and Carol Lewis trying to figure out who dunnit

The detectives paying grilling a suspect

We're confused!

Anita Miller waiting patiently for the answer to her probing question

Tony Ravioli, played by Kirk Mondy

"OK, lets write this down," said Nancy Boyer

I think we have it!

Sher Galeotti explaining that they don't have it

Tony Ravioli getting cuffed by the sheriff

Real handcuffs!

The Winners and their coveted Sherlock trophies

Dancing to Auld Lang Zyne

More dancing